1{
2  "evaluation_id": "fixture-rejected-generic-source",
3  "timestamp": "2026-05-14T00:00:00+00:00",
4  "source": {
5    "url": "https://example.com/generic-ai-tips",
6    "title": "Ten AI Tips",
7    "author_or_org": "Unknown",
8    "published_at": "",
9    "source_type": "other",
10    "retrieval_status": "failed",
11    "primary_or_secondary": "secondary"
12  },
13  "gatekeeper": {
14    "G1_mechanism_specificity": {
15      "pass": false,
16      "evidence": "No concrete mechanism."
17    },
18    "G2_implementable_artifacts": {
19      "pass": false,
20      "evidence": "No code, schema, prompt, diagram, or procedure."
21    },
22    "G3_beyond_basics": {
23      "pass": false,
24      "evidence": "Only basic advice."
25    },
26    "G4_source_verifiability": {
27      "pass": false,
28      "evidence": "Author cannot be verified."
29    },
30    "verdict": "REJECT",
31    "rejection_reason": "Failed all content gates."
32  },
33  "scoring": {
34    "D1_technical_depth_actionability": {
35      "reasoning": "No implementation path.",
36      "score": 0
37    },
38    "D2_repo_relevance": {
39      "reasoning": "Too generic for the corpus.",
40      "score": 0
41    },
42    "D3_evidence_rigor": {
43      "reasoning": "No evidence.",
44      "score": 0
45    },
46    "D4_novelty_insight": {
47      "reasoning": "No new insight.",
48      "score": 0
49    },
50    "weighted_total": 0,
51    "calculation_shown": "(0*0.35) + (0*0.30) + (0*0.20) + (0*0.15) = 0"
52  },
53  "decision": {
54    "verdict": "REJECT",
55    "override_triggered": "null",
56    "confidence": "high",
57    "justification": "The source fails gates and retrieval."
58  },
59  "extraction": {
60    "mechanism": "",
61    "implementable_artifacts": [],
62    "failure_modes": [],
63    "candidate_skill_target": "reject",
64    "candidate_skill_name": "",
65    "taxonomy_category": "harness_engineering",
66    "estimated_complexity": "low"
67  },
68  "human_review_notes": null
69}
70